Symphony: October 2001

Masterworks Diamond Series
Louie, The Ringing Earth
Prokofiev, Piano Concerto No.3
Tchaikovsky, Symphony No.5

Venue: The Orpheum Theatre

Date(s): 19 October, 2001

Reviewer: Jane Penistan

The young south American conductor, Roberto Minczuk, produced a very exciting rendition of Alexina Louie's The Ringing Earth, which was originally commissioned for the opening gala of Expo '86. The opening movement was a joyous explosion of rhythmic sound, with all sections of the orchestra ringing in harmony. The following section was slower and more sonorous, pulsating like the tides of mighty oceans. This work has a magnificence and grandeur suited to a breathing, living, sentient world: The Ringing Earth.

Jon Kimura Parker did not disappoint his admirers at his welcome home to the Orpheum. Prokofiev's number 3 Piano Concerto in C Major. Op 26, was a tour de force for Kimura Parker. He played with ease, the music appearing to flow from his energetic, beautifully controlled fingers.

At times the orchestra tended to overpower this magnificent playing, almost as if they were competing with the soloist, rather than complementing, particularly in the second movement, Tema com Variazione, where the piano variations are so intricate and were so impeccably played. Nevertheless this was an exhilarating performance.

Tchaikovsky's Symphony Number 5 in E Minor, Op.64 was the final offering of the evening. This well known work seems to hold all Russia with its singing themes, dancing allegro, aching loneliness, and its majesty. It was a satisfying close to a most enjoyable concert.

© 2001, Jane Penistan


top / symphony / home